Transmission and distribution of electricity is cheaper in Finland than in other Nordic Countries - thanks to incentive regulation

Electricity transmission and distribution tariffs in Finland are below the European average because incentive regulation forces local monopolies to operate efficiently through cost competition.
The photo shows Professor of Management science Timo Kuosmanen.
Professor of Management Science Timo Kuosmanen. Photo: Aalto University.

Many consumers may sigh when looking at their electricity bill because the share of electricity transmission and distribution in the final sum of the bill may seem unreasonably high. However, tariffs might be even higher without the incentive scheme developed by researchers and Finnish Energy Authority, which promotes the efficient operation of electricity transmission companies.

‘It is challenging to build and maintain a reliable electricity distribution network in a sparsely-populated country like Finland with very demanding environmental conditions, and naturally, it costs something’ says Timo Kuosmanen, Professor of Business Mathematics and Statistics.

‘We have, nevertheless, succeeded in keeping our electricity transmission and distribution tariffs at a low level by European standards and in fact, the average electricity distribution tariffs paid by our households are the lowest in the Nordic countries.’

Cost-effective monopolies

Keeping electricity transmission costs under control has required systematic development and cooperation that researchers of the Aalto University School of Business and have engaged in with the Finnish Energy Authority since the 1990s. The development work has been exceptional, as the same group of researchers has managed to take the advances they have made in basic research areas such as mathematics and statistics into applied research in energy economics, and to further apply them to support policy decisions with great significance for society as a whole.

‘We have developed an incentive scheme that forces local monopolies to compete in a virtual market place in terms of costs and reliability of service. An electricity transmission company can increase its profit if it operates with lower costs than its peers. In this way, the method creates an incentive for monopoly companies to operate cost-effectively. The Finnish Energy Authority has applied our latest method in the regulation of electricity distribution firms since 2016’, Timo Kuosmanen says.

Building an electricity grid is very expensive, and consequently, it is a textbook example of a natural monopoly. In Finland, there are currently about 80 local monopolies in electricity distribution. In addition, legislation updated in 2013 requires strengthening of the electricity transmission grid in order to secure the availability of electricity under exceptional conditions, such as Finland's winter storms. As public finances are scarce, the funding of a weatherproof electricity grid requires private investment.

‘Private investors need guarantees of a reasonable return on equity, but blatant profiteering in provision of a critical service such as the distribution of electricity should be prevented. The incentive scheme that we have developed is an important tool in this’, Timo Kuosmanen notes. 

International interest

Development of the incentive scheme has taken several years, during which the Energy Authority and the electricity distribution companies have faced each other in court. However, the court cases have also proven to be useful.

‘The court cases drew attention to clear needs for improvement in the statistical models that our incentive system utilized, and the researchers successfully responded to those needs. Therefore, the court cases helped to speed up the development of incentive regulation into its current form’, Timo Kuosmanen points out.

The regime developed in Finland is also attracting international interest, because digitalisation and adapting to climate change require strengthening of the distribution networks in different parts of the world.

‘Finland's incentive system can be directly used as a model for other European countries where incentive regulation is currently at a similar stage as ours used to be some 10 - 15 years ago. In other regions such as South American countries, high transmission fees and poor reliability of supply also raise pressure to update the incentive schemes, Timo Kuosmanen says.

Another indication of international influence is that a study recently published by the University of Turku shows that Timo Kuosmanen, with his publications, is the most internationally visible Finnish professor in the specialised fields of business economics. Last year Kuosmanen was invited as a keynote speaker to several international congresses, and in late May and early June his research group presented the latest results of their research at the world congress of the International Association for Energy Economics in Montreal.  

 

Information on the publication:

Kuosmanen T. (2018) Conditional Yardstick Competition. Technical Report, version 2.0.
Link to the publication

 

Other publications on the topic:

Kuosmanen, T. (2012) Stochastic semi-nonparametric frontier estimation of electricity distribution networks: Application of the StoNED method in the Finnish regulatory model, Energy Economics 34(6), 2189-2199.

Kuosmanen, T., A. Saastamoinen, T. Sipiläinen (2013) What is the best practice for benchmark regulation of electricity distribution? Comparison of DEA, SFA and StoNED methods, Energy Policy 61, 740-750.

Saastamoinen, A., T. Kuosmanen (2016) Quality frontier of electricity distribution: Supply security, best practices, and underground cabling in Finland, Energy Economics 53, 281-292.

 

Further information

Timo Kuosmanen
Professor of Management Science
Aalto University School of Business
tel. +358 40 353 8393
[email protected]

 

The photo shows Professor of Management science Timo Kuosmanen.
Talousmatematiikan ja tilastotieteen professori Timo Kuosmanen. Kuva: Aalto-yliopisto.

Kansainvälistä kiinnostusta

Kannustinjärjestelmän kehittäminen on ollut vuosien prosessi, jonka aikana on myös käyty oikeutta Energiaviraston ja sähkönsiirtoyhtiöiden välillä. Kuosmanen kertoo, että oikeusjutuista on kuitenkin ollut myös hyötyä.

”Oikeusjutut toivat esiin selkeät kehittämistarpeet niissä tilastotieteellisissä laskentamalleissa, joita kannustinjärjestelmässä käytettiin. Pystyimme tutkimuksella vastaamaan näihin kehittämistarpeisiin, joten oikeusjutut itse asiassa nopeuttivat kannustinjärjestelmän kehittymistä nykymuotoonsa.”

Suomessa kehitetty järjestelmä herättää kiinnostusta myös kansainvälisesti, koska digitalisaatio ja ilmastonmuutokseen sopeutuminen edellyttävät jakeluverkkojen vahvistamista ja tehostamista eri puolilla maailmaa.

”Suomen kannustinjärjestelmästä voidaan ottaa suoraan mallia muissa Euroopan maissa, joissa nykyisin sovelletaan vastaavia kannustimia kuin meillä 10–15 vuotta sitten. Myös esimerkiksi Etelä-Amerikan maissa korkeat siirtohinnat ja heikko toimitusvarmuus luovat paineita kannustinjärjestelmien uudistamiseksi”, Timo Kuosmanen kertoo. 

Kansainvälisestä vaikuttavuudesta kertoo muun muassa se, että Turun yliopiston äskettäin julkaiseman tutkimuksen mukaan Timo Kuosmanen on julkaisuiltaan Suomen kansainvälisesti näkyvin professori liiketaloustieteellisillä erityisaloilla. Viime vuonna Kuosmanen oli yksi pääpuhujista useissa kansainvälisissä kongresseissa, ja touko-kesäkuun vaihteessa hänen johtamansa tutkimusryhmä esitteli uusimpia tutkimustuloksiaan energiataloustieteen kongressissa Montrealissa.

 

Julkaisun tiedot:

Kuosmanen T. (2018) Conditional Yardstick Competition. Technical Report, version 2.0.
Linkki julkaisuun

 

Muita aiheeseen liittyviä julkaisuja:

Kuosmanen, T. (2012) Stochastic semi-nonparametric frontier estimation of electricity distribution networks: Application of the StoNED method in the Finnish regulatory model, Energy Economics 34(6), 2189-2199.

Kuosmanen, T., A. Saastamoinen, T. Sipiläinen (2013) What is the best practice for benchmark regulation of electricity distribution? Comparison of DEA, SFA and StoNED methods, Energy Policy 61, 740-750.

Saastamoinen, A., T. Kuosmanen (2016) Quality frontier of electricity distribution: Supply security, best practices, and underground cabling in Finland, Energy Economics 53, 281-292.

 

Lisätietoa:

Timo Kuosmanen
talousmatematiikan ja tilastotieteen professori
Aalto-yliopiston kauppakorkeakoulu
puh. 040 353 8393
[email protected]   

  • Published:
  • Updated:
Share
URL copied!

Related news

Apulaisprofessori Arno Solin
Research & Art Published:

”Machine learning excited me before I knew it was a thing”

Arno Solin received funds allocated to young researchers in the summer of 2019. Solin is excited about machine learning, as it offers a way to both delve deep into theory and solve real-life problems.
Yrittäjyyden tutkijatohtori Virva Salmivaara
Research & Art Published:

Virva Salmivaara: I study the role of entrepreneurs in sustainable development

According to the researcher of entrepreneurship, researchers must have a personal vision they believe in, and they need to be prepared to work persistently to achieve their goals.
Aalto University / Verkkoturvallisuus ja -luottamus / photo: Aki-Pekka Sinikoski
Research & Art, Studies Published:

Guest speakers discuss the effects of digitalisation on a public lecture series

How does digitalisation affect business, society and security? Join our public lectures to hear guest speakers from the industry and institutions discuss the hottest issues on digitalisation!
Aalto EIT Services Javor
Research & Art Published:

EIT Festival - 2nd October @Aalto

Welcome to the EIT Festival to discover EIT Innovation Communities in Finland!