Just believing that an AI is helping boosts your performance

People perform better if they think they have an AI assistant – even when they’ve been told it’s unreliable and won’t help them
tekoälyohjelma käynnistyy
Participants were asked to perform a task once on their own and once supposedly aided by an AI system. Image: Otso Haavisto / Aalto University

Sometimes it just seems like an AI is helping, but the benefit is actually a placebo effect – people performing better simply because they expect to be doing so – according to new research from Aalto University. The study also shows how difficult it is to shake people’s trust in the capabilities of AI systems.

In this study, participants were tasked with a simple letter recognition exercise. They performed the task once on their own and once supposedly aided by an AI system. Half of the participants were told the system was reliable and it would enhance their performance, and the other half was told that it was unreliable and would worsen their performance.

‘In fact, neither AI system ever existed. Participants were led to believe an AI system was assisting them, when in reality, what the sham-AI was doing was completely random,’ explains doctoral researcher Agnes Kloft.

The participants had to pair letters that popped up on screen at varying speeds. Surprisingly, both groups performed the exercise more efficiently – more quickly and attentively – when they believed an AI was involved. 

‘What we discovered is that people have extremely high expectations of these systems, and we can’t make them AI doomers simply by telling them a program doesn’t work,’ says Assistant Professor Robin Welsch.

Following the initial experiments, the researchers conducted an online replication study that produced similar results. They also introduced a qualitative component, inviting participants to describe their expectations of performing with an AI. Most had a positive outlook toward AI and, surprisingly even skeptical people still had positive expectations about its performance.

The findings pose a problem for the methods generally used to evaluate emerging AI systems. ‘This is the big realization coming from our study – that it’s hard to evaluate programmes that promise to help you because of this placebo effect’, Welsch says.

While powerful technologies like large language models undoubtedly streamline certain tasks, subtle differences between versions may be amplified or masked by the placebo effect – and this is effectively harnessed through marketing.

The results also pose a significant challenge for research on human-computer interaction, since expectations would influence the outcome unless placebo control studies were used.

‘These results suggest that many studies in the field may have been skewed in favor of AI systems,’ concludes Welsch.

The researchers will present the study at the renowned CHI-conference on May 14. The research paper can be found here.

Aalto computer scientists in CHI 2024

Ten papers from Aalto CS were accepted to the CHI 2024 conference

Illustration of a white-to-light-blue side profile of a human face with network nodes pointing out against a blue background

Blind trust in enhancement technologies encourages risk-taking even if the tech is a sham

A placebo effect can make users overconfident when they think tech is helping them


Finnish Center for Artificial Intelligence (external link)

The Finnish Center for Artificial Intelligence FCAI is a research hub initiated by Aalto University, the University of Helsinki, and the Technical Research Centre of Finland VTT. The goal of FCAI is to develop new types of artificial intelligence that can work with humans in complex environments, and help modernize Finnish industry. FCAI is one of the national flagships of the Academy of Finland.

  • Published:
  • Updated:

Read more news

Publication icon
Research & Art Published:

Publication Forum seeks new panellists for term 2025-2028

If you are interested in becoming a panel member of the Publication Forum (Julkaisufoorumi, Jufo), apply by 15.6.2024.
Matti Vartiainen
Research & Art Published:

New book on flexible hybrid work

Matti Vartiainen explores the shift in working culture and what it means for staff wellbeing and performance, as well as how remote work policies can be implemented effectively.
Textile Chemistry research group
Research & Art Published:

Making textiles greener, safer, and cooler

Professor Ali Tehrani and his research group focus on something very familiar to us all – textiles.
Campus Published:

PechaKucha event tested the presentation skills of doctoral students at the School of Electrical Engineering

The first PechaKucha at the School of Electrical Engineering challenged the school's doctoral students to present the topics of their dissertation in six minutes. The event was held on Wednesday 22 May at Otaniemi A Grid.