Hate speech-detecting AIs are fools for ‘love’

State-of-the-art detectors that screen out online hate speech can be easily duped by humans, shows new study
How Google Perspective rates a comment otherwise deemed toxic after some inserted typos and a little love.

Hateful text and comments are an ever-increasing problem in online environments, yet addressing the rampant issue relies on being able to identify toxic content. A new study by the Aalto University Secure Systems research group has discovered weaknesses in many machine learning detectors currently used to recognize and keep hate speech at bay.

Many popular social media and online platforms use hate speech detectors that a team of researchers led by Professor N. Asokan have now shown to be brittle and easy to deceive. Bad grammar and awkward spelling—intentional or not—might make toxic social media comments harder for AI detectors to spot.

The team put seven state-of-the-art hate speech detectors to the test. All of them failed.

Modern natural language processing techniques (NLP) can classify text based on individual characters, words or sentences. When faced with textual data that differs from that used in their training, they begin to fumble.

‘We inserted typos, changed word boundaries or added neutral words to the original hate speech. Removing spaces between words was the most powerful attack, and a combination of these methods was effective even against Google’s comment-ranking system Perspective,’ says Tommi Gröndahl, doctoral student at Aalto University.

Google Perspective ranks the ‘toxicity’ of comments using text analysis methods. In 2017, researchers from the University of Washington showed that Google Perspective can be fooled by introducing simple typos. Gröndahl and his colleagues have now found that Perspective has since become resilient to simple typos yet can still be fooled by other modifications such as removing spaces or adding innocuous words like ‘love’.

A sentence like ‘I hate you’ slipped through the sieve and became non-hateful when modified into ‘Ihateyou love’.

The researchers note that in different contexts the same utterance can be regarded either as hateful or merely offensive. Hate speech is subjective and context-specific, which renders text analysis techniques insufficient as stand-alone solutions.

The researchers recommend that more attention be paid to the quality of data sets used to train machine learning models—rather than refining the model design. The results indicate that character-based detection could be a viable way to improve current applications.

The study was carried out in collaboration with researchers from University of Padua in Italy. The results will be presented at the ACM AISec workshop in October.

The study is part of an ongoing project called Deception Detection via Text Analysis in the Secure Systems group at Aalto University.

Research article:

Tommi Gröndahl, Luca Pajola, Mika Juuti, Mauro Conti, N.Asokan:
All You Need is "Love": Evading Hate-speech Detection.
https://arxiv.org/abs/1808.09115

More information:

Tommi Gröndahl, Doctoral Candidate
Aalto University
Secure Systems group
[email protected]
tel. +358 400 426 523

N. Asokan, Professor
Aalto University
Secure Systems group
[email protected]
tel. +358 50 483 6465

  • Published:
  • Updated:
Share
URL copied!

Related news

Illustration on beige background: two students painting a big yellow lightbulb.
Press releases, Studies Published:

Apply to Aalto Thesis project: HSL - Software Production 2.0!

Aalto Thesis project's application is open for Master's students. Read more of HSL's project and apply!
Tiina Tuurnala, Alumna of the Year 2019, School of Engineering
Appointments, Press releases Published:

Tiina Tuurnala named as Aalto University School of Engineering Alumna of the Year 2019

'My current position is an excellent vantage point for working toward zero-emission seafaring together with other stakeholders.'
Aiheet, joissa rasismista puhuttiin
Press releases Published:

Discussions about racism strongly differ in the Finnish news media and discussion forums

On the popular Suomi24 discussion forum, users see immigration and minorities as a threat to “the ordinary Finnish people”, while journalists address racism from a historical and international perspective.
DigiEduHack image by DigiEduHack
Campus, Press releases, University Published:

DigiEduHack is reinventing the future of learning and education

DigiEduHack will break continental barriers by connecting around 50 educational institutions worldwide in order to solve the world’s most pressing challenges in digital education