Fusion energy will save our future? True or false: Five claims about fusion power

A breakthrough in fusion energy production was achieved last week when, for the first time ever, the fusion reactions in a small fuel pellet yielded more energy than the pellet had absorbed. The amount of energy produced by a tiny pellet is naturally very small, but the breakthrough is still significant. We asked our researchers, Taina Kurki-Suonio and Eero Hirvijoki, about five claims related to fusion.
Nano cryostat

1. Fusion energy will solve the world's energy production problems.

Kurki-Suonio: Hopefully true
It's extremely important to realize that nothing major can happen in the energy sector on a very quick time scale. Change has to be measured in decades rather than years. The energy system is quite stiff, so right now saving energy is the key. However, this is certainly brilliant news. With fusion, we're in new territory and cannot know for sure what we'll find.

2. Fusion energy production is completely emission free.

Hirvijoki: False
Although the fusion process itself does not release any greenhouse gases, producing fusion energy is not completely emission free. Every single technology we use for electricity or heat production requires construction materials, and the production of raw materials currently is not emission free.

3. In the quest for fusion, all efforts should now be directed to the technology that produced this breakthrough.

Kurki-Suonio: False
Even in research, it makes sense not to put all your eggs in the same basket, so to speak. Two kinds of technologies have been explored to harness fusion energy: inertial confinement fusion (ICF) and magnetically confined fusion (MCF).  For decades, MCF has been far ahead, with steady (but less stunning) progress. Therefore, a single 'leap' discovery in ICF does not justify abandoning MCF. Several DEMO-class reactors that will demonstrate electricity production using MCF are being developed not only in Europe but also at least in China, Korea and the US – each with a somewhat different approach based on the same principle.

4. Researchers at Aalto University carry out globally significant fusion energy research.

Kurki-Suonio: True
At Aalto, we have three focal areas: Material research, power exhaust and supra-thermal particles. All of these topics are at the cutting edge of the most relevant research towards fusion energy.

Hirvijoki: True
At Aalto, we do a lot of massive simulations. We're talking about computing power comparable to hundreds of thousands if not millions of ordinary laptops. This is where artificial intelligence comes into the picture. The goal is to create simplified models derived from the heavier first-principles models. These would capture the most relevant information for making predictions while also relieving the computational burden. Ultimately, the common goal of the simulations done by researchers around the world could be described as something like a flight simulator for a fusion device.

5. All students should have basic understanding of energy.

Kurki-Suonio: True
An unbiased understanding of the pros and cons of different energy production mechanisms is the only way to secure the future of today's youth. It's even more important to understand and adopt a reasonable and responsible approach to using energy. That's why every student should get a basic understanding of the energy field: what we can do to guarantee 24/7 production of energy that meets the needs of the society in a sustainable manner. Then they can decide if some energy sector interests them to study further.

Taina Kurki-Suonio is a senior university lecturer and leader of the ASCOT research group at the department of applied physics. She is also engaged in energy issues at EU level as the vice chair of the ESFRI energy Strategic Working Group.

Eero Hirvijoki is an academy research fellow and university lecturer at the department of mechanical engineering.

  • Published:
  • Updated:

Read more news

Eemeli Mölsä being promoted as doctor
Cooperation, University Published:

Doctoral level expertise is needed as ABB is engineering the energy transition

Joint doctoral research projects between Aalto University and ABB are training scientists to develop the cutting-edge products needed in the future.
Cone Calorimeter Testing
Research & Art Published:

BIOSUOJA project is saving lives by developing bio-based fire retardant coatings

A talented group of young researchers is making these non-toxic coatings out of wood.
A visual AI-generated sketch for urban development in Battersea district in London
Cooperation, Research & Art, Studies Published:

Architecture students use AI to design social innovations for London

The project combined qualitative evolutionary design and visual generative artificial intelligence, for the first time.
The picture shows the menu, in which the CO2 emissions are marker with color codes and the price in euros.
Press releases, Research & Art Published:

New research: Labeling carbon footprint affects the choices of mass catering customers – and the labeling method matters, too!

A recent study conducted in Germany shows that customers in a student canteen choose low-emission meals when presented with the carbon footprint of meals. This effect was strongest when the information was color-coded in a traffic-light scheme and translated into environmental costs in euros. According to one of the researchers, these findings could also be relevant for Finland, where mass catering is particularly popular.