Events

Public defense in Organization and Management, M.Sc. Kaja Lilleng

How investors judge social and environmental aims shapes which ones come to count as valuable, and which futures follow.

Title of the thesis: Value in the making. Public defense from the Aalto University School of Business, Department of Management Studies.
Doctoral hat floating above a speaker's podium with a microphone.

In our events, we are committed to Aalto University’s principles for a safer space.

Title of the thesis: Value in the making

Thesis defender: Kaja Lilleng
Opponent: Prof. Eva Boxenbaum, Copenhagen Business School, Denmark
Custos: Prof. Nina Granqvist, Aalto University School of Business 

Valuation—assessing and giving value to things—runs through nearly every corner of social life, from a painting argued over by critics before it is priced at auction to a start-up given a financial value based on a future it has yet to deliver. How something comes to be seen as valuable is rarely without consequence, and few settings make this clearer than finance. As capital is increasingly called upon to address social and environmental challenges, it matters how investors judge what is valuable.

Kaja Lilleng’s doctoral thesis, Value in the making, explores how social and environmental value is engaged with and constructed in finance. The research is set in impact investing, where investors seek positive impact alongside financial returns, and focuses on early-stage investments, made into companies before there are profits to show or impact to measure. These companies are judged less on what they are than on what they might become, and on whether investors believe that potential is worth backing. The thesis draws on in-depth qualitative studies of Nordic early-stage impact investors, as well as an ethnographic study of the inner workings of a pioneering venture capital fund.

The findings show that more than financial logic is in play when investors assess and give value. Moral and qualitative judgements shape what comes to be seen as a ‘good investment’, and investors differ markedly in what they consider impact to be in the first place. The time horizons within which investments are made also shape how value is assessed in the present, at times in counter-intuitive ways.

Judging value and constructing value, the thesis argues, are entwined. In deciding which social and environmental aims qualify and count as valuable, investors have a hand in making them so, and their judgements carry forward, shaping what gets funded and built, and which futures come into view.

In foregrounding qualitative, moral, plural, and temporal sides of valuation that have received less attention in studies of financial settings, the thesis contributes to economic sociology, the sociology of finance, and valuation studies. For investors, fund managers, and policymakers working to direct capital towards long-term social and environmental goals, the findings can help make visible the judgements built into their practices, and what it takes to value differently.


Key words: valuation practices, social and environmental value, time horizons, impact investing, venture capital, sustainable finance, economic sociology

Thesis available for public display 7 days prior to the defence at Aalto University's public display page. 

Contact information: 

Kaja Lilleng, kaja.lilleng@aalto.fi

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kaja-kirstine-h-lilleng/

Doctoral theses of the School of Business

A large white 'A!' sculpture on the rooftop of the Undergraduate centre. A large tree and other buildings in the background.

Doctoral theses of the School of Business at Aaltodoc (external link)

Doctoral theses of the School of Business are available in the open access repository maintained by Aalto, Aaltodoc.

  • Updated:
  • Published:
Share
URL copied!