News

Finns were reluctant to share election tweets of bots

According to the final report of ELEBOT project, the effect of Twitter bots was minimal during this year’s Finnish elections
Kuvituskuva, jonka pohjana käytetty visualisointia eduskuntavaaleihin liittyvistä aihetunnisteista

The number of Twitter bots and their influence on the Finnish elections this spring were minimal. Researchers make this conclusion in the final report of ELEBOT project. Despite the small number of bots, the results indicate that bots distribute unequally over the internet.

Bots produce either real or distorted information in an automatized manner. They are one form of information operations that aim to influence on, for example, election results. Aalto University researchers found information operations in content shared on Finnish Twitter before the Finnish parliamentary and European elections. However, bot tweets received only little attention from normal Twitter users who seemed reluctant to retweet content created by bots.

Before the parliamentary election, a bot wrote only half percent of all retweets by normal users and 0.7% of retweets were written by a so-called stopped account. Stopped accounts are user accounts that Twitter has closed or frozen due to spam or another security risk. Before the European elections, equivalent proportions stayed below half percentage.

The difference is large in comparison to, for example, the US mid elections held in November 2018. In the US elections, more than 35 percent of bots’ tweets were retweeted at least once. Researchers of ELEBOT project used same measures that have been used, for example, in the US elections.

The distribution of bots is unequal

According to the report results, bots tweeted mainly about the same topics as normal users. However, bots and normal users retweeted different types of tweets and interacted with different users. This suggests that bots’ operate unequally over the internet.

By using the most popular retweeted topics, the researchers were able to visualize communities whose members were more linked to their in-group members than users of their out-group.

The researchers recognized the three largest communities that were visualized in green, purple, or blue in the report. The smallest community was the blue one, formed by about seven percent of all users. In it, the relative share of certain hashtags – often relating to immigration or the right wing populist Finns Party – was larger than in the other communities. Nearly eight percent of bots and stopped accounts belonged to the blue community.

In the European elections, the distribution of bots and stopped accounts was similar to that in the parliamentary election. In the blue community, less than 2% users were bots, but they interacted with each other quite often; around 14% of all interactions between bots and stopped accounts happened in this community. Based on visual observations, such interactions were more frequent in the blue community than in other communities.

Suurimmat yhteisöt visualisoituna. Mukana myös niiden käytetyimmät aihetunnisteet.
The large picture visualizes the three largest communities by using green, purple, and blue colors. The most shared hashtags of the communities whose tweets were shared most often are included in the picture (in Finnish).

Twitter isn’t the only platform for information operations

The data gathered for the parliamentary election analyses included 188,668 unique users who published more than 1.3 million tweets in total. For the European elections analyses, the number of tweets in Finnish was 490,000, and 46,000 users tweeted about the elections. When more global topics were taken into account, the number of relevant tweets increased to nearly 660,000 and the number of Twitter users around 118,000.

About five and half percent of the Twitter users who tweeted about election themes before the parliamentary election were bots. They created 2.5% of all election-related tweets. During the EU elections, around 2.8% of all users tweeting about the elections were bots, producing 1.8% of all election-related tweets.

Even though the number of bots and their influence was minimal, researchers point out that the model used for bot-recognition may be unable to recognize all bots. Bots progress quickly and creating a better model calls for deeper development work. It is also important to remember that a normal user who isn’t classified as a bot can try to influence public discussions in a similar manner as a bot.

Information operations may have occurred also in other social media channels. In principle, Twitter is an open platform and the data collected by it is easy to access. The extent to which bots had effect on elections would be best discovered by taking into account also other platforms, such as Facebook. However, many services are more difficult to research as they tend to less open than Twitter.

Researchers gathered data by using the Twitter API from January 20 to April 15 for the parliamentary elections. They studied the tweets related to the EU elections from April 14 to May 31.

The report published by Aalto University has been written as part of the ELEBOT project that has been funded by the Finnish Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Education and Culture. In addition to the funding parties, the steering group of the project included representatives from the Finnish Security Committee and Prime Minister’s Office.

Link to the research report (in Finnish): https://aaltodoc.aalto.fi/handle/123456789/39200

Further information
Mikko Kivelä
Assistant Professor, Department of Computer Science
Phone 050 3824 555
[email protected]

Raimo Kantola
Professor, Department of Communications and Networking
Phone 040 7501 636
[email protected]

Further information about the report content and analytics
Ali Salloum
Research Assistant, Department of Computer Science
[email protected]

Tuomas Takko
Research Assistant, Department of Computer Science
[email protected]

  • Published:
  • Updated:

Read more news

Two hexagonal arrays of prisms with a blue lattice inbetween.
Research & Art Published:

New quantum entangled material could pave way for ultrathin quantum technologies

Researchers reveal the microscopic nature of the quantum entangled state of a new monolayer van der Waals material
Cone Calorimeter Testing
Research & Art Published:

BIOSUOJA project is saving lives by developing bio-based fire retardant coatings

A talented group of young researchers is making these non-toxic coatings out of wood.
The picture shows the menu, in which the CO2 emissions are marker with color codes and the price in euros.
Press releases, Research & Art Published:

New research: Labeling carbon footprint affects the choices of mass catering customers – and the labeling method matters, too!

A recent study conducted in Germany shows that customers in a student canteen choose low-emission meals when presented with the carbon footprint of meals. This effect was strongest when the information was color-coded in a traffic-light scheme and translated into environmental costs in euros. According to one of the researchers, these findings could also be relevant for Finland, where mass catering is particularly popular.
Dr. Swarnalok De and logos of the Finnish Cultural Foundation, Aalto University and MMD group
Research & Art Published:

Dr. Swarnalok De receives a one-year grant from the Finnish Cultural Foundation

Awarded for research on the development of wearable healthcare sensors for autonomous health monitoring of the aging population